Behind the Bar: Star Pubs v Gunmakers Arms
In this episode, Richard and Lizzie unpack the County Court’s decision in Star Pubs Trading Ltd v Gunmakers Arms (Essex) LLP and what it means for landlords, tenants, pub operators, and commercial property lawyers.
The court ruled that Star Pubs could successfully oppose lease renewal under Ground G of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954, despite day-to-day pub operations being carried out by a third-party contractor.
Why? Star Pubs still controlled the pricing, branding, contracts, marketing, and overall retail strategy. The business, legally speaking, remained theirs.
Richard explore’s what “occupation for your own business” really means in modern commercial leasing, why physical presence is not the deciding factor, and how this case fits alongside authorities including Humber Oil Terminals Trustee Ltd v Associated British Ports, S Frances Ltd v Cavendish Hotel (London) Ltd and Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea v Mellcraft.
Relevant cases:
Humber Oil Terminals Trustee Ltd v Associated British Ports [2012]
Cunliffe v Goodman [1951]
S Frances Ltd v Cavendish Hotel (London) Ltd[2012]
Dellneed Ltd v Chin (1987)
Brumwell v Powys County Council [2011]
Teesside Indoor Bowls Limited v Stockton-on-Tees Borough Council [1990]
Graysim Holdings v P&O Property Holdings [1996]
THE LEADING UK REAL ESTATE LAW FIRM
We are the UK’s largest and most experienced specialist real estate law firm, trusted by leading clients in the property sector for over 25 years.
With over 75+ senior lawyers, each bringing an average of 25 years’ post-qualification experience from top-tier private practice and in-house roles, we offer unparalleled expertise across the full range of real estate legal services — including commercial property, planning, construction, environment, real estate finance, property litigation, and more.
Our exclusive focus on real estate law uniquely positions us to support fellow professional services firms through our Real Estate Support solution. We deliver specialist legal expertise to the UK Top 30, silver circle firms, US Top 50, and the Big Four.
Whether you’re a developer, investor, occupier, institution, or advisor, we provide clear, commercial, and responsive legal advice — helping you to get the job done.