Paying for a Gym You Can't Use? Notting Hill Home Ownership v Samoail and others
In this episode of Unpacking the Case, we examine the Upper Tribunal's decision in Notting Hill Home Ownership Ltd v Samoail and Others [2026] UKUT 235 (LC), a significant ruling for landlords, housing associations and shared ownership providers.
The Tribunal confirmed that shared ownership leaseholders cannot be required to pay service charges for parts of an estate that fall outside the scope of their sub-lease and which they are unable to access. The decision dismissed appeals brought by Notting Hill Genesis and followed disputes involving substantial service charge demands, with some residents facing bills of more than £6,000 to contribute towards maintenance.
We explore why the wording of leases remains crucial, and the wider implications for service charge recovery, estate management and shared ownership developments across England and Wales.
Whether you advise landlords, manage residential developments or work in the affordable housing sector, this episode highlights an important reminder that service charge obligations must be rooted firmly in the rights and responsibilities set out in the lease.
Relevant Cases:
Chartbrook Ltd v Persimmon Homes Ltd [2009]
THE LEADING UK REAL ESTATE LAW FIRM
We are the UK’s largest and most experienced specialist real estate law firm, trusted by leading clients in the property sector for over 25 years.
With over 75+ senior lawyers, each bringing an average of 25 years’ post-qualification experience from top-tier private practice and in-house roles, we offer unparalleled expertise across the full range of real estate legal services — including commercial property, planning, construction, environment, real estate finance, property litigation, and more.
Our exclusive focus on real estate law uniquely positions us to support fellow professional services firms through our Real Estate Support solution. We deliver specialist legal expertise to the UK Top 30, silver circle firms, US Top 50, and the Big Four.
Whether you’re a developer, investor, occupier, institution, or advisor, we provide clear, commercial, and responsive legal advice — helping you to get the job done.